Best Insurance Agent in Columbus, IN

We Shop Insurance, So You Don’t Have Too

At Robert Hufty Agency, the mission revolves around empowering clients with knowledge about their insurance options. As dedicated insurance advisors under Goosehead Insurance, the goal is to find the best coverage while ensuring clients have a clear understanding of their choices. By partnering with top mortgage loan officers and realtors, we facilitate the protection of assets with optimal pricing, making insurance more than just a quote.

Start New Quote 317-743-0272

M322648 - Hero Trust Badges .png

Our Insurance Services

Choosing the right insurance is crucial, and a variety of services are offered to meet diverse needs:

Home 1.png

Auto Insurance

This coverage protects against damages to your vehicle, as well as liability for injuries or property damage caused to others. Comprehensive and collision options are available to tailor the policy to unique needs.

Learn More

Home  2.png

Home Insurance

Customized home insurance is designed to secure your residence and personal belongings from unexpected damages. It provides coverage for various perils, giving you peace of mind.

Learn More

Home  3.png

Life Insurance

With life insurance, clients can ensure that their loved ones receive financial protection in the event of life’s unforeseen circumstances. It secures the future of families, helping them maintain their lifestyle without financial strain.

Learn More

Home 4.png

Renters Insurance

While renters may not own the physical building, this insurance covers personal belongings against disasters, theft, or damages. It’s an essential safeguard for valuables in a rented home.

Learn More

Home 5.png

Umbrella Policies

This extra layer of liability coverage kicks in beyond standard homeowners or auto insurance, providing additional protection and peace of mind.

Learn More

Services 6.png

Get Started

Our team of experts is here to help you meet your insurance needs. We are the team to trust for trustworthy and reliable services!

Start New Quote

M322648 -  Five Start.png

About Our Insurance Agency

Backed by Goosehead Insurance, Robert Hufty Agency is committed to offering expert advice and personalized service. Access to more than 40 A-rated insurance carriers allows for efficient navigation through the insurance landscape, ensuring clients receive policies tailored to their unique needs.

A figurine of a home

Why Choose Us

Choosing Robert Hufty Agency ensures you receive top-notch service and expert guidance. Key benefits include:

  • Tailored coverage options

  • Professional advice and support

  • Quick and efficient service

  • Strong partnerships with industry experts

  • Commitment to client education

Start New Quote

Home page 2.3.png

We Work With The Best Insurance Companies

While there may be hundreds of providers out there, our team has vetted the best options for your needs.

What our customers are saying

Michael H.

"It's easy to say the biggest reason is the money saved. But I also expanded my auto coverage by quite a bit, in addition to saving extra money. Robert was also very patient in explaining things and answering my questions. Also, one time in the middle of our phone call, I had to interrupt Robert to abruptly leave the call to take another urgent call - something that could frustrate anyone. But Robert showed not even a hint of it bothering him - he seemed very understanding and we picked up our call where we left off 20 or 30 min later. I appreciate his understanding and patience with me."

Malia J.

"I saw my rates go up a significant amount over the past year alone, with 0 claims, incidents, or change,s and reached out for a quote before my renewal time was up and Shella worked her magic on a Friday evening after normal business hours to get my info submitted and find me a great rate with better coverage ultimately saving me hundreds of dollars! She's super personable, very responsive, and great to work with!"

Brandi E.

"Robert took the time to thoroughly explain my policy to me. He was accessible kind and patient. Even when I shopped around, I was more comfortable choosing Goosehead because I knew exactly what I was getting, and I'm confident in the coverage."

Ready to get started?

With a focus on delivering exceptional value and comprehensive solutions, Robert Hufty Agency is dedicated to providing the best insurance options for every client’s needs. Experience the difference that comes with working with a knowledgeable and committed team.